A Parents' Guide to Defusing Defiance: Building a Stronger Relationship Instead of Battling Behavior
Nov 10, 2024
Let’s face it: defiance from kids can feel like a mini-rebellion in the family. You ask for their shoes to go on, and instead, they dramatically flop onto the floor in a grand protest. You ask for a room to be cleaned, and you’re met with crossed arms and that “make me” look. It’s a classic scene every parent has experienced, usually just when you’re running late. But what if we could see defiance not as a personal attack on our authority but as a signal about our relationship with our child?
Experts in positive parenting argue that defiance is rarely a “behavioral” issue and more of a “relationship” issue. When our kids push back, they’re not just trying to drive us to early gray hair (although they certainly have the power). They’re often trying to communicate a deeper need for connection, understanding, or autonomy. It’s almost like they’re saying, “Hey, pay attention to this relationship—we need a tune-up!”
Instead of beating yourself up about this being a relationship issue, show yourself some compassion. You have been doing the best that you could as a parent with the skills that you have. But, good news: there are more skills available to help!
Let’s dive into a few ways to strengthen that connection and reduce the drama without losing your sanity (or sense of humor).
1. See Defiance as Communication, Not Combat
Dr. Daniel Siegel, co-author of The Whole-Brain Child, suggests that children often don’t yet have the vocabulary or emotional skills to express complex needs. Defiance can actually be a form of communication, signaling that something isn’t right. Maybe they’re feeling disconnected, or perhaps they’re overwhelmed or exhausted. “Connection is the key,” Siegel says. “When children feel safe and connected, they are more likely to cooperate.”
Instead of treating every defiant act like a battle to win, try to see it as a window into what your child needs. Asking, “What’s really going on here?” can sometimes open the door to a more meaningful connection. Sometimes, what seems like defiance may just be a plea for quality time or some independence.
2. Validate Their Feelings, Even if You Don’t Approve of Their Behavior
It might sound counterintuitive, but empathizing with your child’s frustration (without giving in) is a powerful way to defuse a tense moment. Dr. Laura Markham, author of Peaceful Parent, Happy Kids, explains that “When we empathize with our child’s emotions, they feel heard, and that calms them down.” You might say, “I know you really don’t want to do your homework right now. That’s tough when you’d rather be playing.”
Validating feelings doesn’t mean endorsing behavior. It simply helps them feel understood—and kids are a lot less likely to defy someone who understands them. Plus, it can save you from becoming their primary emotional target.
3. Give Choices, Within Reason
Let’s be real: kids love control. The more we say, “Because I said so!” the more likely they are to say, “Oh yeah?” with a look that makes us question our life choices. Offering choices is a genius positive-parenting move because it gives kids a sense of autonomy without actually giving up parental authority. For example, instead of saying, “Put on your shoes now,” try, “Do you want to wear the blue shoes or the red ones?”
Jane Nelsen, author of Positive Discipline, says, “Where did we ever get the crazy idea that in order to make children do better, we must first make them feel worse?” Choices empower kids to make decisions, which builds self-confidence and also reduces power struggles. Just make sure the choices are ones you’re actually okay with!
4. Make Room for Problem Solving Together
When you and your child hit an impasse, consider working together on a solution. Think of it as a mini team meeting. For example, if your child resists bedtime, you could say, “I can see bedtime is tough for you. Let’s figure out a way to make it easier together.” Collaborating on solutions shows kids that their feelings matter and models how to resolve conflicts respectfully.
“Kids are much more likely to comply when they have some say in what happens,” says Alfie Kohn, author of Unconditional Parenting. You might be surprised at the creative solutions they come up with—and they’ll be more motivated to follow through because they helped make the plan.
5. Laugh Together – A Lot!
It’s easy to forget that sometimes, humor is the fastest route to defuse a tense situation. A little laughter can break the tension and remind both of you that, at the end of the day, you’re on the same team. Instead of reacting with frustration, try getting silly. Use a funny voice, make a silly face, or do an exaggerated sigh that says, “I’ll never understand this homework situation!” Sometimes, a shared laugh can soften defiance into cooperation.
Playful parenting can make discipline feel less like “us vs. them” and more like “we’re in this together.” Laughter reminds them (and you) that love doesn’t vanish just because you’re both frustrated. And sometimes, it’s that reminder that strengthens the relationship in a way that no rule ever could.
6. Remember: It’s Not About Perfection, It’s About Progress
It’s easy to fall into the trap of wondering why you haven’t nailed this whole parenting thing yet. But keep in mind that positive parenting is a process, not a product. We’re not aiming to turn our kids into flawless beings, nor are we striving to be perfect ourselves. We’re just trying to grow, connect, and strengthen our relationships one day (or one defiant act) at a time.
When your child is pushing back, know that it doesn’t make you a bad parent. It just makes you a parent. And if you can see defiance as a sign that your relationship could use a little TLC, you’re already doing it right.
Final Thoughts: Embrace the Beautiful Mess
Defiance can be exhausting, yes, but it’s also a natural part of growing up and pushing boundaries. When we treat it as a relationship signal, rather than a behavior that needs to be crushed, we can work with our children to build trust, connection, and mutual respect. You might even find yourself feeling grateful for these moments of challenge because they give you the chance to teach (and learn) about patience, understanding, and love.
So, the next time you’re staring down a defiant stare, take a deep breath, crack a smile, and remind yourself: this isn’t a war—it’s a chance to reconnect. And who knows? Maybe one day, you’ll look back on these moments and laugh about the battles fought over mismatched socks!
Parenting Alongside You!
Dr. Emma and the Aparently Parenting Team
(Click the hyperlinks to purchase any of the books we mention above. We are part of the Amazon affiliate program so if you make a purchase through our links we do make a few pennies each time. That helps us continue to offer these resources for free!)
SUBSCRIBE FOR FREE PARENTING RESOURCES
We know you're busy! So, we'll make sure to only send the IMPORTANT PARENTING stuff!!
We hate SPAM. We will never sell your information, for any reason.
