Articles

When Halloween Tantrums Aren’t Bad Behavior-Understanding Dysregulation in Disguise

Oct 07, 2025

It started with excitement.
Costumes were laid out, pumpkins were glowing, and sugar was flowing.

Then suddenly, it wasn’t fun anymore.

Tears. Shouting. A slammed door. The costume that “didn’t feel right.” The candy argument that spiraled into full-body frustration.

I used to think these moments meant my child was ungrateful or acting out. Now, I know better. What looks like “defiance” or “tantrums” on the surface is often something far deeper — a child whose nervous system has lost its footing.

What’s Really Happening Beneath the Meltdown

Halloween is thrilling, but it’s also unpredictable. Loud sounds, flashing lights, unfamiliar faces, late bedtimes, sugar surges, itchy costumes, and emotional highs all collide at once.
To an adult, this might sound like a long day.
To a child’s brain, it can feel like danger.

When the brain perceives too much stimulation, the amygdala (the brain’s alarm system) takes control, and the prefrontal cortex — the logical, reasoning center — temporarily shuts down. This isn’t a choice. It’s survival. In addition to the brain, their body's nervous system is switching into a fight, flight, freeze or fawn state.

That’s what’s happening during a “tantrum.”
Your child’s system is flooded. Their body is signaling: I’m overwhelmed and I don’t know how to get back to safety.

No amount of reasoning, consequences, or lectures can reach a brain or nervous system in that state. The only thing that can help is co-regulation — our calm, attuned presence signaling safety to their system.

Why Behavior Isn’t the Enemy

When we focus only on the behavior — the yelling, stomping, or defiance — we miss the communication underneath it.
All behavior is a message.
It’s not “bad” or “good”; it’s data.

A meltdown says, I can’t hold it all right now.
Defiance says, I’m scared of losing control.
Refusal says, I need safety before I can cooperate.

Once we view behavior through this lens, we can respond with compassion instead of control.

How to Support a Dysregulated Child

1. Regulate before you reason.
Start with presence, not words. Lower your voice. Breathe slower than feels natural.
A nervous system in distress needs another calm nervous system nearby to anchor it.

You might say softly:

“You’re having such a big feeling right now. I’m here. You’re safe.”

That one sentence communicates more than any lecture ever could.

2. Create physical safety.
If possible, reduce stimulation: step into a quieter space, dim the lights, or take a short walk outside. The body must first feel safe before the brain can re-engage.

3. Validate the experience.
You don’t need to agree with their words to acknowledge their emotion. Try:

“That was really loud, and it startled you.”
“It’s hard when things don’t go the way you imagined.”

Validation doesn’t reward behavior. It rewires trust.

4. Co-regulate through your own body.
Your calm tone, open posture, and steady breathing tell your child’s body, you’re not alone. Children learn to regulate by borrowing our calm.

5. Repair afterward.
When everyone has cooled down, reflect gently:

“That was a tough moment. You were so frustrated. What might help next time?”

Repair teaches resilience — that relationships can bend without breaking.

Rethinking “Discipline” on Days Like Halloween

In connection-based parenting, discipline isn’t about punishment; it’s about teaching.
We teach most effectively when both brains and nervous systems are calm. That means saving big conversations for the next day, when your child’s nervous system (and yours) has returned to balance.
Halloween is temporary. Connection is lasting.

Tips For Parents, Too (Your Nervous System Is Impacted As Well)

When your child loses it, your own body often reacts in kind.
You might feel your pulse quicken, your voice tighten, your patience slip.
That’s your nervous system responding in parallel.

If you find yourself snapping or withdrawing, give yourself the same compassion you offer your child.
Take a breath. Step away if needed. Then return and repair. Our calm doesn’t have to be perfect — it just has to be genuine.

The Takeaway

A Halloween meltdown isn’t a failure of parenting or of the child. It’s a moment that reveals just how powerful the nervous system truly is — and how much our presence matters.

When we choose connection over correction, we show our children that even the scariest moments can end in safety, trust, and love. The real work of parenting isn’t about preventing every storm. It’s about learning to be the steady hand in the middle of one.

Parenting alongside you,
Dr. Emma & The Aparently Parenting Team

SUBSCRIBE FOR FREE PARENTING RESOURCES

We know you're busy! So, we'll make sure to only send the IMPORTANT PARENTING stuff!!

We hate SPAM. We will never sell your information, for any reason.

Articles

When Halloween Tantrums Aren’t Bad Behavior-Understanding Dysregulation in Disguise

SUBSCRIBE FOR FREE PARENTING RESOURCES

Join Our Free Trial